Taiwan-born Hoping Chen is a film editor and long-time collaborator of Singaporean director Anthony Chen (Photo: courtesy of Hoping Chen)
Cover Taiwan-born Hoping Chen is a film editor and long-time collaborator of Singaporean director Anthony Chen (Photo: courtesy of Hoping Chen)

From travel shows for TV to award-winning films like ‘The Breaking Ice’ (2023) and ‘Katya and the Scarlet Sails’ (2012), Hoping Chen is no stranger to helping tell stories that resonate with global audiences

When we think of movies, we typically think of the actors and actresses who starred in the film, or the director who led the project. However, there is a whole army of people who work behind the camera to bring a film to the screen for audiences to enjoy. You only have to think about the many categories, both televised and not televised, that were included at the 96th Academy Awards this month—and how many winners thank the cast and crew of the films they’re in—to have an understanding of how many departments are involved in bringing a movie to life.

One role that is crucial to putting an engaging, entertaining and cohesive story together is the film editor, who works closely with the director on a project to make sure every frame and every beat of the movie is perfect.

Last month, Tatler spoke with Hoping Chen, a Taiwanese film editor and long-time collaborator of Anthony Chen—the Singaporean director behind the Cannes Film Festival and Golden Horse Film Festival awards-winning Ilo Ilo (2013). Hoping talked to us about how she found her place in the film industry, why representation matters throughout production and not just on screen, and Drift, her latest project with Anthony that will be released in the UK later this month.

Read more: From drama to comedy, 10 women-led films to watch for a dose of empowerment

When did you first realise film editing is something you could do, and how did you become an editor?
It started quite early, because I started watching films when I was five or six years old with my grandparents. My family loves watching films. Storytelling was always my passion. So I started wanting to be a writer when I was quite young. And when I went to university I was in the mass communications department, and out of all the courses, I loved photography and filmmaking. 

I started as a screenwriter and [was] involved with Wonders of the World, which was the first travel TV show in Taiwan. So I travelled around the world for five years to make the show. After that, I felt I needed to do something else, so I became a documentary filmmaker. It was while I was making documentaries that I had my first chance of editing my own documentary. So that’s how I learnt on the job, but I wasn’t really good at it. Later, when I got assigned to make a drama series for another TV company, I realised that editing was a craft I needed to learn. So I decided to go to the National Film and Television School [in the UK], which has the best course focused on film editing.

That’s where you met Singaporean director Anthony Chen and where your collaboration first started?
I met him when we were in our first year, and I cut his first-year film, Hotel 66.

We always see the directors, the actors—but they can’t make a film without us.

- Hoping Chen, Taiwanese film editor -

Are there many women in the film industry?
At the moment, I’m also teaching at a film school, and from my observations a third [of the graduating class] is women. It was very encouraging to have three very talented women in the cinematography course [out of a class of ten]. Cinematography is considered a bit more difficult for women [because working with cameras is a very physical job]. But in the editing course, it’s about half and half.

But when we started, as a woman applying for jobs in the UK, [I didn’t notice an imbalance of genders]. But when you get to a certain level you realise, “oh, most of the really established and successful editors are male.” Maybe because more directors are male … but we are working through it, and I think that will improve.

As a woman and an Asian person, why is it important to have representation not only in front of the camera, but also behind the camera?
Because you can’t make a film without all those people. We always see the directors, the actors—but they can’t make a film without us. So it’s crucial to highlight the people behind the scene, because every single element of a film is made by the talents of those artists, who don’t always get awarded or seen. 

So many actors say that, ultimately, it’s the editors and directors who get to decide what the film becomes in the editing room. What’s it like from an editor’s perspective to receive all these takes from the performers and how do you turn that into a beat that fits into the bigger story?
Usually there are many takes and the director will say which one is the best, but—not always, but very often—that’s redundant because in the editing room we try to make sure every scene has a focus, and where we make sure everything is perfect. So maybe there is something that’s just not perfect [with the director’s favourite take], so we have to change it. So the whole decision is in the editing room, it’s in the editors’ hands.

Have you ever found yourself having a different opinion to the director, and how do you handle a situation like that?
If we can sit together, then we just need to argue and discuss, and see which one of us is convinced. For me, I’m not one of those editors who will just follow the director, because if we do that, then the director should cut the whole film. 

[Anthony Chen has] everything in his head, but I still have my creativity. He wouldn’t say to me, “you can’t do this”. He’d always let me do the first draft on my own. So I would do a cut and we would watch it. Parts of it would be as he’d planned, but parts of it would not, just because I felt there’s a better way. Sometimes, if he’s pleasantly surprised he’ll happily accept it. But if he doesn’t like it, it’s not a problem. In the editing room he’s very open.

Tatler Asia
Hoping Chen at a premiere of “Drift” (Photo: courtesy of Hoping Chen)
Above Hoping Chen in Taipei for the screening of ‘The breaking ice’ (Photo: courtesy of Golden Horse Film Festival)

What is it about your working relationship with Anthony Chen that makes it such a good collaboration for the both of you?
We really share the same style. Anthony is a great lover of Taiwanese cinema from the ’80s. So in that way, I feel like we grew up together in that culture.

We met by chance. He’s Singaporean, I’m Taiwanese, and he's 21 years younger than I am. When I first met him, Anthony was already very successful. He’d made short films in Singapore and went to Cannes ... I thought, “maybe this young guy is a little showy.” But when we worked together, I realised, “wow, although he’s young, he has an old soul.” The way he looks at stories is very mature and he’s a very talented genius in filmmaking.

It’s a very stressful industry, and when it’s someone you have faith in, you know they will create magic without you asking. Challenges? It’s the basic things, like even though you know someone so well, you still need to respect them. We need to be aware that we can’t take anything for granted, and you need to open your mind. Because otherwise everything would be the same and there would be no point in making it.

What are you excited for audiences to see in Drift, your latest project with Anthony Chen that stars two-time Oscar nominee Cynthia Erivo?
It’s exciting because while it’s not my first English project, it’s Anthony's first English film. This film is so precious to me because the process of making it—for me, all the crew, and Anthony—was quite a journey. The result is a quiet, beautiful piece that has this really powerful inner strength. It's really rare to have this kind of film, and I hope people will go to cinemas to watch it.

What would you say to anyone who is at a point in their career where they are facing a transition?
Never doubt yourself because of the possibility of difficulties. I went to film school when I was 45 years old. If you have this feeling of wanting to do something, then try your best to do it even if it seems impossible.

Topics